BackStartups

Control & governance

Employee option pool

Also called ESOP, Share option scheme

Shares reserved for issue to employees as options, giving them the right to buy at a fixed strike price and share in the company's growth.

In plain English

An option pool is how startups pay people they could not otherwise afford. An employee receives the right to buy shares at a strike price set today, usually the current market value of ordinary shares. If the company grows, the difference between the strike and the eventual value is theirs. If it does not, the options are worthless and cost the employee nothing but opportunity.

Pools run from roughly 10% to 20% of the company, with the size negotiated at each round. Grants vest on the same four-year, one-year-cliff pattern as founder shares, and unexercised options usually expire ninety days after an employee leaves — a provision that has caused a great deal of unhappiness, since an employee who has vested valuable options may be unable to fund the exercise cost and the associated tax bill within three months.

The strike price is set by an independent valuation of the ordinary shares, which is typically a substantial discount to the last preferred round price because ordinary shares lack the preferences, vetoes and protections that the preferred price paid for. In the United States this is a 409A valuation; other jurisdictions have their own equivalents.

Tax treatment varies enormously and materially affects how valuable options are to employees. The UK's EMI scheme is unusually generous; many jurisdictions tax at exercise on paper gains, which can leave employees with a bill and no cash.

What it means for your cheque

The pool dilutes you, and it is the dilution most worth accepting. A company that cannot attract good people because it has no equity to offer will not produce the outcome you invested for. The question is never whether there should be a pool but whether it is sized to a real hiring plan.

What to look for in diligence: how much of the existing pool is unissued, whether grants have actually been documented and board-approved rather than merely promised, and whether the company uses a tax-advantaged scheme where one exists. Undocumented promises are a cap-table problem that surfaces at the worst moment.

Do the arithmetic

What an early employee grant is actually worth

An employee joins at seed and receives options over 0.5% of the company, with a strike price set at the ordinary share valuation. The company exits at $300m six years later.

Grant at seed0.5% of the company
Strike pricethe ordinary-share valuation at grant — a fraction of the preferred round price
Position after four rounds of dilutionabout 0.21%
Gross value at a $300m exitabout $630,000
Less exercise cost and taxvaries by jurisdiction and scheme
If the employee left in year three75% vested, 90 days to exercise, cost payable in cash

The upside is real and the 90-day exercise window is the trap. An employee who leaves before an exit often cannot fund the exercise, and forfeits options they genuinely earned.

At the table

What to negotiate

  • Ask how much of the existing pool remains unissued before agreeing to a top-up.
  • Check that grants are documented and board-approved, not promised in offer letters and never issued.
  • Ask whether the company uses an available tax-advantaged scheme — EMI in the UK, and local equivalents elsewhere.
  • Look at the post-termination exercise window. Extending it beyond 90 days is increasingly common and treats employees better.
  • Confirm the strike price is supported by a current independent valuation.

Around the world

How this differs by market

Employee option pool: common questions

Why is the strike price lower than the last round price?
Because options are over ordinary shares, and the round price was for preferred shares carrying liquidation preferences, veto rights and anti-dilution. An independent valuation prices the ordinary shares separately, and the discount reflects the rights they do not carry.
What happens to options when an employee leaves?
Unvested options are forfeited. Vested ones typically must be exercised within 90 days or they lapse — which means paying the strike price and often a tax bill in cash, at a point when the shares cannot be sold. Longer exercise windows are increasingly common and much fairer.
Should I object to a large option pool?
Object to a pool that is not sized against a real hiring plan, not to pools in general. Equity is how startups hire people they cannot afford to pay, and an under-resourced pool damages the company far more than the dilution damages you.